The Junior Accountant (You)
← Big Four prep

Think like an auditor

Interviewers do not expect you to know auditing standards. They want to see that you think the way a good auditor thinks. These are the ideas behind that.

1Be professionally sceptical

A good auditor keeps a questioning mind. Not cynical, and not accusing anyone, but never accepting a number just because someone says it is right. The question is always: how do I know?

When the client's controller says an area is always fine, the sceptical answer is friendly but firm: then the test will be quick.

2Know what you are testing for

Every figure in the books makes silent claims. Auditors call them assertions. Each test you do is there to check one of them.

Existence

Is it real?

The bank confirmation proved the 31,200 of cash really is in the bank.

Completeness

Is anything missing?

January payments revealed December electricity that was never booked.

Cut off

Is it in the right year?

A deposit for a January event had been booked as December revenue.

Valuation

Is it worth what the books say?

A gym that closed down would never pay its 1,200, so it was written off.

Accuracy

Are the amounts right?

Salaries of 70,000 matched 7,000 a month for 10 months.

Rights and obligations

Does the company really own it, or really owe it?

The bank confirmed the loan of 15,000 is owed by this company.

3Prefer strong evidence

Not all evidence is equal. The more independent it is from the client, the more you can rely on it.

  • StrongerSent straight to you by an outside party, such as a bank confirmation.
  • StrongerSomething you saw or did yourself, such as attending the stock count.
  • StrongerWritten documents, and several sources that agree with each other.
  • WeakerDocuments prepared by the client, which the client could change.
  • WeakerA spoken explanation with nothing to back it up.

4Focus on what matters

Auditors cannot check everything, so they decide how big an error must be before it matters to a reader. That is materiality. They then spend most time where errors are most likely and would be biggest. That is the risk based approach. Revenue, for example, is presumed to carry a risk of fraud on every audit.

5Test a sample, then judge the whole

Instead of checking every one of thousands of invoices, auditors pick a sample, test it carefully and draw a conclusion about the whole. Bigger and riskier items are more likely to be picked. If the sample finds errors, the auditor asks what that means for everything that was not tested.

6Habits that make a good associate

  • Write everything down. In audit, if it is not documented, it did not happen.
  • Ask why. A number that moved a lot needs an explanation you can check.
  • Raise problems early, calmly and with your evidence.
  • Protect client information. Never discuss it in public.
  • Stay independent. Be friendly with the client, but do not accept favours.

Put it into practice

Every idea on this page comes up in the audit level, where you find four real errors and sign off.